
“I can see…a Lighthouse. It’s Glorious!”
Welcome back, residents of Mockburg! (Mocktown? Borough of Mockery? Mockeropolis?) It’s good to see you.
There is trouble brewing for NHL hockey in the New York City area. The difficulties for the New York Islanders in securing civic approval for a new arena and multi-use development around the proposed facility has left team owner Charles Wang dropping not-so-veiled threats about possible relocation for the franchise with four Stanley Cups.
The Islanders have gone so far as to play a pre-season game at the acclaimed yet unoccupied, luxurious and aesthetically pleasing new Sprint Center, which pines for a major league tenant, or in this case even the National Hockey League. Unfortunately for the hosts in KC, a.k.a. arena and sports conglomerate Anschutz Entertainment Group (AEG) and the city government, the town found a baseball game of more interest than the hockey game that night. Or maybe the Chiefs-mad Kansas City crowd thought that the sad-sack Scouts had a game that night and went to Kemper Arena to see them instead of the Isles. Unfortunately, the Scouts had bailed after two miserable seasons in the early ’70′s. Either way, only about 5,000 eager fans came out to convince Mr. Wang that his best bet was in Kansas City according to local news reports, and KC, like Atlanta, were ready for the NHL again.
I can only imagine what was going through Wang’s mind as he looked out on the former future home of his franchise: “Thanks for the great steaks, but apparently the worst arena in the NHL on Long Island is better than a brand new on in Kansas City.”
After returning to Long Island, he’s dropped the other shoe by threatening to move, issued deadlines, and pretty much everything he can do to wring approval for a new arena but pick up the shoe he dropped and beat it on a desk in a County Council Meeting. We can only hope that’s coming soon to YouTube. Unfortunately Charles Wang, you are not getting the green light any time soon on Long Island.
As an accomplished and highly suspected successful business person, you should recongnize that you will have to cut your losses with the local political machine. You surely see that in the New York market, everyone has their hand in your pocket, everything costs twice as much to build, and most times it takes forever to get done. For examples of these wonderful Big Apple quirks, just see what’s gone on at Ground Zero, New Yankee Stadium, Citifield, the New Meadowlands Stadium, the proposed Barclays Center in Brooklyn, and the Prudential Center that is in dangerous Newark, instead of thriving Hoboken where it was originally planned. But after all of these lonely years out there in the middle of the parking lot, surrounded but detached from suburban Long Island, struggling with the political do-nothings, it looks as though you may have lost some perspective on the project.

Fleet Week is always popular with the Islanders Ice Girls
The truth is, sports in New York are a Love/Hate relationship. You’re either loved or hated, a hero or a bum. The loss of two baseball teams, a basketball team that hops from arena to arena in the Nets, and watching both New York NFL franchises move their stadium and all facilities to New Jersey has burnt the New York Sports Fan once too often. There are 9 pro sports teams in the New York City market representing the Big Four sports, and three hockey teams to boot. And that’s just major league sports. Will anyone really care if there are only two hockey teams to watch in the New York area? At least you can get to the survivors’ games via mass transit.
How long do you think the locals will complain after how the Islanders have beaten their fan base into submission with mediocre hockey (at best) in a dump of an arena these many years? It’s been over 25 years since the Isles’ amazing run of four straight cups. Those fans who were adults to see those seasons have retired to Florida by now, going to Lightning games, or not going to see the Coyotes in Phoenix. Anyone under 25 hasn’t seen anything but heartache, the banners, and the stories of glory. No, there’ll be some tears, and it’s a horrible thing, but the best option for the long-term viability of the franchise, the NHL, and Charles Wang is this:
Move the team to the Greater Toronto Area.
NO! WHAT?! The outrage is palpable. It is a sad thing when a franchise moves and leaves a fan base behind. That’s why when the Islanders move to their new home, and with it the pre-approved new facility in the Toronto market, they will leave behind the name Islanders, and those 4 championships. The name will lie dormant, but only for a little while. A new franchise will be born, and if need be they will play in the Air Canada Center until their home arena is completed, which it must because any owner will want the revenue from their own facility instead of paying rent.
Toronto is the most underserved Hockey market in the world. It is a crime against the fans of the highest valued franchise in the NHL that it cannot get the job done on the ice. It seems like an inside joke between the NHL and the Leafs, the long con at its best. No one can stop the misfortunes of the hometown Leafs, and the league fails to satisfy excess demand by putting another team in Toronto through relocation or expansion. Scarcity is an economic driver of demand. Well, it seems that Ontario is in a frenzy for hockey, and it’s time to listen to the market.
By moving the Islanders there, Wang can either sell for an inflated premium, which he probably deserves for his tenure with the team (although the Mike Milbury years scarred many fans). The Indemnity Fee to the Maple Leafs that the league has said they will set will be paid by the new owner, or by Wang if he decides to stay on with the team. Either way, you’ve put a guaranteed revenue engine for the league in place, rescued a beleaguered franchise and moved it to Hockey Heaven. You’ve removed the worst arena in the league from the NHL inventory. And you’ve created an instant sports rivalry because of the relocation between the biggest city in the US and the biggest city in Canada. And keep in mind that having some competition for the hockey dollar in Toronto might do wonders to motivate Maple Leafs management to ice a quality, competitive, playoff caliber hockey team for a change. How cool would that be for Ontario, Canada, the majority of fans and the league. Every one is happy, except Islander fans and the owners,who would potentially lose out on a huge expansion fee because of the Toronto market’s value.

The game can handle another church in the Toronto Diocese
Well, in this fantastical world where this move happens, there is even a silver lining on Long Island for fans and the league’s coffers. Wang will not leave the Island without a Happy Ending (Ooof). There will be a team in New York again. Never mind that there three teams in the area are too many, that’s a blog for another day. But if the Brooklyn arena is finished, it only makes sense to put a team there. Paying rent and revenue steams become an issue again, so maybe losing the team temporarily will motivate the politicos in Hempstead to move forward with approval for an arena for the reconstituted franchise on Long Island. And the league gets to expand into the area again if they so choose, and by retaining the Islander’s name and marks, the NHL can get the new owners around paying an indemnity fee to the Rangers and Devils by arguing that the new Islanders franchise was merely suspended and not new.
Even if the new Islanders take some to reappear, at least that would improve the fortunes of the New Jersey Devils. The animosity between Islander and Ranger fans means there probably wouldn’t be many Isles’ fans who would start rooting for their hated rivals. New Jersey is the only other local hockey option, and people can actually get to the game by train. Something they can’t do at the Coliseum in Nassau. By the way, this is an immutable law of successful sports arenas in the US, and a mantra of this blog. You MUST have mass transit access. Anywhere on the East Coast from Washington to Boston. That’s just the way it is. Ideally, you build in urban centers and use the facility to revitalize the downtown core. Fans can get from Manhattan to Newark in about 15 minutes by train, so it’s not much added time or effort to get your hockey fix in a brand new arena compared to the hassle of getting to an Isles game. Lord knows the Devils could use some fans. Lou Lamoriello may be in the Hockey Hall of Fame, but he is no Marketing Genius. It would be a great chance to fill those empty seats at the Rock.
In 1972, the NHL gave Long Island a franchise to keep the upstart WHA from putting a team in the newly completed Coliseum. New York had two teams up until the 40′s, so it was a good business decision for the NHL to lock out the competition from the largest market in the country. People were moving to the suburbs, White Flight was in full force, and the arena’s location reflected the rapidly changing demographics of the time. But times have changed again, and people are moving back into the cities. It’s just about impossible given the traffic congestion around New York to get from work to home to pick up the family, and then make it to the game on time. Add that even if Wang’s vision, the Lighthouse project, even gets built, the new arena is only a small part of the project. It is the surrounding development where Wang stands to make his money. Just as much would be made by moving to Canada, though. It may take a little longer, and it’s not as glamorous as building a new city on Long Island, where Wang lives. But a franchise in the Toronto market is guaranteed to keep laying golden eggs, even if the team loses. Just look at the Leafs.
As much as it stings, Long Island, you’ve had your chance. If you want to keep your team, vote out your elected officials who don’t believe NHL Hockey, the storied Islanders franchise, and a new arena are in the community’s best interests. Elect someone who will cut through the bureaucracy. Build a new arena and keep your franchise. It’s that simple. Otherwise, the NHL is leaving, and won’t return without a new building. Regardless, it’s time for another team in the Greater Toronto Area. Until Long Island gets their act together and resolves the embarrassment that they consider an arena, maybe it’s just an AHL territory. It would be a shame to find out.

What Leafs games might look like if there was another team in Toronto